Take Your Brain Someplace Fun!   |   Contact Us

Mystery Dinner Theatre Boston MA

Looking for a Mystery Dinner Theatre in Boston, MA?

If you are looking for mystery dinner theatre Boston MA, you’ve probably come across some nasty reviews on Yelp. What is up with Yelp? Two stars and mostly, old bad reviews from years past are recommended. If you click to see all reviews, the plot thickens. You’ll find several positive reviews, especially the most recent ones. We’ve worked diligently to improve the experience, but you can’t please all of the people all of the time but… we try!  There is no way to prove those reviews are from real, paying customers. If you want  legitimate reviews from verified ticket holders, check Zerve. The reviews from Zerve paint a much different picture. Thank goodness! It makes you wonder what is going on with Yelp. Of course, we think we’re fun, interactive, and awesome! You need to decide for yourself, but make sure you have all the facts.

Mystery Dinner Theatre Boston Reviews



The Mystery Cafe is Boston’s original mystery dinner theatre, and we’re still around. Those are pretty good facts that speak for themselves.

Here are some reviews from our most recent shows:

From “A Deadly Christmas Carol”

Beautiful Location, Hysterical Show, Great Food
Thu, Dec 18, 14   7:00 PM sturso Female 30-39 Local Group of Friends
The food was wonderful. The service was amazing. The actors were hysterical. The way they included the audience made the show that much more enjoyable. The location was beautiful. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience for our office holiday party.

From ComedySportz Boston (Yep, that’s us too!)

This is a great show for 15 BUCKS!
Sat, Jan 10  7:00 PM Lorettamosca Female 50-59 Local Family With Children
We went with a a group of our college age children, it was a fun affordable family night. We all laughed and were entertained the entire time. Good clean for all ages and then of course then there is endless places to eat in Davis Square. It was a great night out with our adult children.

From “Murder Most Medieval”

Rating: 5
Fun evening
Sat, Dec 27, 14   7:30 PM RGBianchi Male 50-59 Local Family With Children
From arrival to departure, we were well taken care of. Good fun and a great meal. The actors were very attentive to not only their roles but also to their duties as hosts. We had a great time.

From “Mobfellas”

The show was fantastic!!!! Food and performance!
Fri, Dec 12, 14   7:30 PM spectorshan Female 60-69 Local Couple on a Date
This troupe of actors and actresses did an outstanding job from the moment our feet hit the landing and straight through the evening. Best interactive show we have ever attended! And the food was phenomenal!!!! Recommending it to everyone we know and we will also return to the restaurant to enjoy many meals in the future!!

Yep, those are 2014 and 2015 reviews. Don’t get caught up on some old Yelp review from 2009, that was a long, long time ago. There are so many exciting things happening at the Mystery Cafe this year! You won’t want to miss Finnegan’s Wake, Endicott Abbey, and Hooray for Hollywood coming this summer.

Contact Us

Buy Your Tickets

To purchase tickets please call us at

Follow Us

Buy Tickets!